Documentation · 04 of 07

Judges and rubric

Every score, vote and commentary in CCDD is an original judgment by a qualified adjudicator made within the competition procedure, under one rubric fixed before the competitions.

01 · Minimum qualification
Experience
≥ 3 yrs

of competitive debate experience

Tournaments
≥ 10

with a qualifying placement

Match-level best-debater awards
≥ 5

plus at least one tournament-wide best-debater award

Qualified adjudicators
157

registered in the pool; 129 of them adjudicated the retained matches

02 · Assignment and procedure

Three judges per match

Each match was assessed by three judges selected from the pool. They scored every evaluated side and stage against the rubric and cast the impression, stage-based and decisive votes and three best-debater votes.

Scores before commentary

Scores and votes were submitted after the match and before public commentary, so one judge's stated view could not shift another's sheet. Individual submissions are retained.

Appeal panels

Twenty retained matches were reassessed by a second panel of three. Appeal judgments stay linked to the original match and separate from the original panel; seven of the twenty outcomes were reversed.

03 · Full stage-level rubric
ScoreTask PerformanceBattlefield JudgmentDegree of Advancement
10Perfectly completedCorrect and important battlefieldDecisive advancement
9Perfectly completedCorrect and important battlefieldMajor advancement
8Well completedCorrect and important battlefieldSubstantial advancement
7Well completedCorrect and important battlefieldEffective advancement
6Well completedCorrect and important battlefieldAn attempt to advance
6Well completedCorrect but secondary battlefieldEffective advancement
5Approximately completedCorrect but secondary battlefieldAn attempt to advance
4Approximately completedCorrect but largely irrelevant battlefieldAn attempt to advance
3Not completedIncorrect battlefieldAn attempt to advance
2Not completedIncorrect battlefieldNo advancement
1Not completedIncorrect battlefieldCounterproductive effect

Each row associates a combination of criteria with a suggested overall score; both profiles for score 6 are retained. "Battlefield" denotes the point of contention selected for engagement. Models in Task 2 receive this same rubric.

04 · Side-specific scoring rules

Constructive speeches are scored for the speaking side. Questioning and cross-examination are scored separately for the questioning side (organisation and progress of attacks) and the responding side (defence and handling of attacks). Head-to-head is scored for each side's attack and defence. Free debate is scored relatively: the larger the gap, the closer the stronger side to 10 and the lower the weaker side. A score reflects the stage alone; earlier stages provide context but do not contribute.

← BenchmarkLicense and terms →